Areas of Study
Research Methods
Data Tables
Contact Us
Site Map
Related
Links
|
2007 Healthy Hall Focus
Group Report - Community Service Leaders
This focus group meeting brought together 15
leaders of Gainesville area community service organizations such as the
United Way, YMCA, children’s advocacy groups, women’s advocacy
organizations, adult education and others. While some have been at their
posts for decades, and some are relative newcomers, all are intimately
aware of the issues and trends that influence quality of life in Hall
County.
What are the best things about life in Hall? The
lake, of course, and the small town feel the area clings to despite
decades of booming growth. This group is in a position to better see and
appreciate the compassion and generosity of the community, which makes
services like theirs possible.
These leaders believe the strength of the
community rests on the forward thinking of its people and the resolve
the community displays to do the right thing.
One participant who had been in the area only
about a year, remarked at how impressed she was when she got "the
book"—a thick listing of resources available in the community. Turns out
"the book" is the compilation of community resources prepared by United
Way 2-1-1.
Though there is a lot this group admires about
Gainesville and Hall County, they do see troubling developments that
undermine quality of life.
Unbridled Growth
These leaders not only work in Hall County, most
live in Hall, and they worry about the consequences of growing
population and related building boom in the area. "We are becoming
Gwinnett," said one, referring to Hall’s more urban neighbor to the
south.
There is a hope that growth can be managed to
protect the traditional small-town feel of Gainesville and surrounding
areas.
Hostility Toward Immigrant Community
Many in this group see a persistent hostility
toward the immigrant community, and worry about its impact on community
life. Though there has been a lot of effort to welcome and accommodate
immigrants, particularly
Latino immigrants, resentment persists in many
areas. Hostility toward immigrants contributes to fear and distrust on
the part of the immigrants themselves.
As leaders of service agencies, these
participants also experience difficulty communicating with the Latino
community. Difficulties with communication makes it more difficult for
Latino residents to assimilate into community life, address issues
collectively and absorb information about community resources.
Shrinking Mental Health Resources
A rising worry is shrinking resources for mental
health and substance abuse treatment. There are very few options for
care for low-income residents and virtually none at all for Latino
residents battling alcohol and substance abuse, and other behavioral
health problems.
"Mental health is way under the radar screen. The
counselors in the schools are in a crisis," said one participant, who
said it takes six months or more to secure an appointment with a child
psychiatrist.
16.4% of Hall
County adults report they have had difficulty
accessing mental health services. This is a slight increase
over 2003 when 13.3% reported the same difficulty.
Source:
Healthy Hall
Community Assessment, 2007
Growing Disparity Between Rich & Poor
Hall County is an affluent community, but it is
also home to a large number of poor households. The immigrant population
is an element of this growing problem.
Community leaders point out that the affluence of
the county means that, despite the large number of poor, the county does
not qualify for some grants and resources that could help address some
problems.
One of the barometers of growing poverty is the
increase in Title 1 schools—schools that receive special designations
and funds because of the large number of poor students they serve. One
person said 700 new poor students are entering schools each year.
The problems of the poor are exacerbated for
those living in rural areas of the county. As one participant put it,
there are resources available in Gainesville, but those in outlying
areas can’t get to them. The lack of public transportation in rural
areas is a complicating factor.
High School Drop Out Rate
Poverty in one generation promotes poverty in the
next. Teens from poor families drop out of school and go to work as soon
as possible to help meet family needs. Without education, the new
generation remains in poverty as they enter adulthood and start their
own families.
One participant reported that the dropout rate
for Hall area schools is recorded as 12.7%, but is likely higher.
These leaders acknowledge that the county has
been proactive providing adult educational opportunities. They would
like to see greater collaboration with businesses to encourage those who
drop out of schools, as well as immigrants who lack education, get what
they need while continuing to work.
These social service leaders are practical. They
realize that affordable labor supports a vibrant business community.
They would like to see practical strategies, however, to try to break
the cycle of poverty and dropping-out.
32% of Hall County
8th and 10th graders think about dropping out
of school at least some of the time. "Boredom" is the most
commonly cited reason for thinking about dropping out.
Source:
Hall County
School System Safe & Drug Free Schools & Communities Report, 2007
Health Insurance
Those in this group are unanimous in praise of the Hall County health
care system. The problem is not health care, they say, but health
insurance. Too many people don’t have health insurance, can’t get it at
work, and can’t afford it, even when it is available.
As one participant put it, "If you have insurance, you are served,
there is every service imaginable. But if you don’t have insurance, you
are surrounded by beautiful doctors offices, but you can’t go."
The problems with insurance are going to get worse as insurance costs
rise and as qualifications for subsidized programs like PeachCare for
children push more people into the uninsured ranks.
Many without insurance are working poor, who either work part time
jobs or work for companies that do not provide benefits. Others could
perhaps afford health insurance, but they don’t understand its value. As
one participant put it, people need to think about their priorities.
"They can have a cell phone or they can have health care. They can have
cable television or they can have health care."
Families & Youth In
Crisis
"Parents have their heads in the sand," said one community leader
about the rise in youth risky behavior. "Our kids are very sexualized
and they are growing up very fast."
These leaders, many of whom work with youth and families in crisis,
see parents abandoning their essential, traditional roles in teaching
their children. They point out that some parents don’t want to
discipline their children or set boundaries. Like school counselors, the
see too many parents who want to be friends with their children rather
than be parents. They don’t want to enforce consequences for bad actions
and decisions. This group also sees parents buying alcohol for their
children and friends.
A lack of parent-enforced boundaries is contributing to a variety of
youth problems, including pregnancy, drug use, gang involvement and a
lack of respect for authority. Community leaders see a growth in
substance abuse problems, sexually transmitted diseases and even AIDS
among youth.
When asked to identify solutions to the problems that face Hall
County families, this group focused on education for troubled youth and
disengaged parents. They would like to see area agencies work together
to teach parenting skills and improved decision-making for youth. These
leaders see education as the key, but acknowledge that traditional
methods may no longer work.
These leaders would like to see parents held to a higher standard of
accountability. As one put it, he would like to see more programs aimed
at "building up men as leaders in their homes, to re-establish authority
and give direction." He points out that many fathers have abandoned
their roles as anchors for their children.
While not everyone agrees on the right approach, all agree that
addressing the breakdown of families and the problems of youth at risk
is a high priority for the future of the county.
Key Observations From Community Service
Leaders
Resentment toward the growing immigrant population
undermines connections in the community and promotes distrust and
fear.
Mental health treatment services are hard to access, especially
for low-income and Latino residents. Ongoing budget restrictions at
the state and federal levels will make the access problem worse in
years ahead.
There is an increasing gap between rich and poor that should not
be ignored. Children from poor families tend to drop out of school
to work and support their families, which perpetuates the poverty
cycle.
The greatest health problem in the county is not availability of
health services, but rather access to health insurance. The ability
to access needed health care is diminished for those without health
insurance. Many workers cannot afford health insurance. Some could
afford it, but choose to spend their money on other things because
they do not see value in health insurance.
Youth risky behavior—alcohol, drugs and sexual activity
primarily—is a major problem in Hall County, but many parents just
don’t get it. In fact, some parents encourage youth risky behavior
by facilitating access to alcohol or failing to teach and
discipline.
There is a need for expanded education and communication
targeting parents and youth, but especially parents. Parents should
be encouraged to accept greater accountability for the behavior of
their children.
|
Focus Group Table of Contents Purpose
African Americans
Community Service Leaders
Latinos
School Counselors & Nurses
Seniors
South Hall
Youth |